| 2022.23 | Elias Pettersson |
| 2021.22 | Thatcher Demko |
| 2020.21 | No All-Star Game |
| 2019.20 | Quinn Hughes, Jacob Markstrom, Elias Pettersson |
| 2018.19 | Elias Pettersson |
| 2017.18 | Brock Boeser (MVP) |
| 2016.17 | Bo Horvat |
| 2015.16 | Daniel Sedin |
| 2014.15 | Radim Vrbata |
| 2013.14 | No All-Star Game |
| 2012.13 | No All-Star Game |
| 2011.12 | Daniel Sedin, Henrik Sedin, Alex Edler, Cody Hodgson (YoungStars) |
| 2010.11 | Ryan Kesler, Daniel Sedin, Henrik Sedin, Alain Vigneault (Coach) |
| 2009.10 | No All-Star Game |
| 2008.09 | Roberto Luongo, Mason Raymond (YoungStars Sophmore) |
| 2007.08 | Henrik Sedin, Roberto Luongo (voted a starter, unable to attend) |
| 2006.07 | Roberto Luongo (voted a starter) |
| 2005.06 | No All-Star Game |
| 2004.05 | No All-Star Game |
| 2003.04 | Markus Naslund (Western Conference Team Captain), Todd Bertuzzi (voted a starter), Marc Crawford (Assistant Coach) |
| 2002.03 | Markus Naslund, Todd Bertuzzi, Ed Jovanovski, Marc Crawford (Coach) |
| 2001.02 | Markus Naslund, Ed Jovanovski |
| 2000.01 | Markus Naslund, Ed Jovanovski |
| 1999.00 | Mark Messier |
| 1998.99 | Markus Naslund, Mattias Ohlund |
| 1997.98 | Pavel Bure, Mark Messier |
| 1996.97 | Pavel Bure |
| 1995.96 | Alexander Mogilny, Pavel Bure (fan vote, could not play due to injury) |
| 1994.95 | No All-Star Game |
| 1993.94 | Pavel Bure (fan vote) |
| 1992.93 | Pavel Bure (fan vote) |
| 1991.92 | Trevor Linden, Kirk McLean |
| 1990.91 | Trevor Linden |
| 1989.90 | Kirk McLean |
| 1988.89 | Paul Reinhart |
| 1987.88 | Greg Adams |
| 1986.87 | Soviet Rendez-Vous (no game) |
| 1985.86 | Tony Tanti |
| 1984.85 | Thomas Gradin |
| 1983.84 | Darcy Rota (replaced Tony Tanti) |
| 1982.83 | John Garrett (replaced Richard Brodeur) |
| 1981.82 | Harold Snepsts |
| 1980.81 | Tiger Williams, Kevin McCarthy (vote) |
| 1979.80 | Lars Lindgren |
| 1978.79 | Challenge Cup (no game) |
| 1977.78 | Dennis Ververgaert |
| 1976.77 | Harold Snepsts |
| 1975.76 | Dennis Ververgaert |
| 1974.75 | Tracy Pratt, Gary Smith (vote) |
| 1973.74 | Bobby Schmautz, Jocelyn Gueuremont |
| 1972.73 | Bobby Schmautz |
| 1971.72 | Dale Tallon |
| 1970.71 | Dale Tallon |